Made the Papers™A Hidden Lens History game
November 17, 2026
Today’s ThemeAnimal Antics

Made the Papers™

Five rounds. Two strange stories each. Only one made the paper. Choose which one you think is real, then see the proof.

The receipt · Original newspaper headline
Your score

🔥 Streak: 0

Explore the Real Stories

Tap a headline to visit the original newspaper.

SSearch millions of historic newspapers on Newspapers.com

Hidden Lens History may earn a commission if you subscribe through an affiliate link. Archive access may be required.

Read the real stories · Spoilers

The five historical items from this edition, with their newspaper proof. Play first if you want to guess.

Round 1 · Historical item

Cow Walks Into a Grocery While Its Companion Eats Lettuce From the Sidewalk Stand

The St. Louis Post-Dispatch gave two animals different shopping assignments: a cow went into the grocery, while her companion ate lettuce from the stand outside. Both details appear in the headline crop.

Cow Goes Into the Grocery

St. Louis Post-Dispatch · 1909-06-20

Open the original newspaper ↗
Round 2 · Historical item

Crow Steals a Windshield Wiper From a Car and Buries It

The Mansfield News Journal reported a crow stealing a windshield wiper and burying it. The paper topped the item with the comparison “Like a Goat.”

Like a Goat

Mansfield News Journal · 1936-04-07

Open the original newspaper ↗
Round 3 · Historical item

Police Answer a Call and Find Stray Horses; Paper Asks if They Stole the Beer

The Appleton paper asked whether horses had stolen bottled beer. Its subheadline says police called to a home at three in the morning found only stray horses in the backyard. The headline poses a question; it does not prove the horses took anything.

Did Horses Steal the Bottled Beer?

Appleton Weekly Post · 1910-09-22

Open the original newspaper ↗
Round 4 · Historical item

Goat Butts at Its Own Reflection in a Shop Window

The Argos Reflector printed an illustrated item about a goat butting at its own image in a show window. The clipping contains the headline and a drawing of the encounter.

Goat Butts at His Own Image in Show Window

Argos Reflector · 1909-12-09

Open the original newspaper ↗
Round 5 · Historical item

Zoo Sheep Raised With a Kitten Stalks Birds and Takes an Interest in Catnip

The Times-Democrat reported a zoo sheep brought up with a kitten. The subhead describes eating meat, stalking birds, arching its back and enjoying catnip. The paper added one important distinction: the sheep did not purr.

Zoo Sheep Acts Just Like a Cat

Times-Democrat · 1912-09-03

Open the original newspaper ↗

Some links are affiliate links. Hidden Lens History may earn a commission if you subscribe. Archive access may be required.

Result copied